(Hartford Courant) Friday before the state legislature’s banks committee, Dr. Henry Backe of the Orthopedic Specialty Group in Fairfield hoists a list of pension plans allegedly plundered by New York investor Bernard L. Madoff. Backe says he personally lost 17 years worth of retirement savings to Madoff.
Backe urged legislators to support stronger federal oversight and more federal relief for those whose pensions were affected by the Madoff scandal. He described Madoff as an “economic terrorist” who ruined people’s trust in pension plans, which he said will eventually “kill our economy.”
First off – federal oversight does little to nothing to prevent this type of thing. Remember Worldcom & Enron? Terrible frauds which wiped out employee’s retirement savings. Solution: More federal oversight. Outcome: Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
Sarbanes-Oxley was supposed to essentially stop frauds with magic fairy dust or something – I don’t recall. But the whole gist at the time was that the federal government would step up oversight, tighten rules, force companies to shovel gobs of money at accounting firms, and utopia would arrive. So they created a deeply flawed set of regulations and laws full of loopholes and nonsense.
Surprise, surprise – Madoff still pulled off his fraud, did he not? Stanford Financial Group still pulled off a fraud, did they not? Why? Because Sarbanes-Oxley is a piece of legislation crafted by industry via a group of neophytes with little understanding of the subject matter, next to no understanding of common sense and zero honesty.
Not only that, but some people who were interested in possibly investing in, or emulating Madoff looked into his fund and determined that it was a fraud. There was no possible way for Madoff to be doing what he was doing.
They dug deeper and then alerted the Federal government.
The government’s response: nothing.
Multiple agencies, different personnel, different evidence and stories – didn’t matter. Henry Markopolos identified 29 red flags in a letter to the SEC in 2005 with a conclusion that Madoff was running a Ponzi scheme. The SEC did – nothing.
So, back to the solution. How exactly does increasing federal oversight make things peachy? How does it ensure this doesn’t happen again? The government had the whole smoking case in front of them – they didn’t even have to find it – and they still blew it. The government had Sarbanes-Oxley put in place to prevent frauds yet full of exceptions and loopholes so that it didn’t even cover Madoff. And, if it had covered Madoff – it wouldn’t have mattered.
In any case – we have this doctor now (among others) who are trying to get more federal relief to help bail them out of their losses. Here is the problem. Federal relief means the next door neighbors and guys 30 states over are being forced to give their hard-earned money away to bail someone else out. Hard working families who are living paycheck to paycheck need to bailout the doctor who was busy making 10% a year annualized from some snobby financier? Sounds like a lovely scheme.
Did this physicians’ practice do their due diligence and get a good understanding of how Madoff was making money? Or did they blindly throw their money at him since he was making gobs of cash for everyone else? I think I know the answer.
Secondly, even if they did their due diligence and everything checked out (which it most assuredly wouldn’t have) – why is it my problem? Life isn’t fair. Terrible things happen to great people everyday.
If it is reasonable to force everyone in this country to hand over money to people who lost money – don’t we also need to make everyone who lost money in the stock market 100% right as well? How about all the people who lost money in 401(k) accounts at Enron & Worldcom – should they come back for their savings? How about people who made bad business deals and lost money – should they be made right?
Eventually – everyone is owed money from everyone else – or, the people who made the wise decisions end up putting all their money into the people who made poor decisions. The Madoff scam was terrible. The guy should be beaten with a tire iron and made to live in a shanty town with roaches and rats for the rest of his life. Maybe inject him with some tuberculosis or cholera so that he can feel what living in poverty is.
On the other hand – I am not responsible for the bad investment decisions of others (just as you are not responsible for mine). If I buy a car from a dealership and the engine goes out on it the next day – you aren’t responsible.
I am just so deeply flummoxed at a society whereby everyone thinks they have a right to a perfect life. You don’t. Perfect lives don’t exist in real life. Bad decisions without ill consequence breeds bad decisions.
If banks made bad decisions – they should go out of business. If people made bad decisions – there needs to be consequences. If you run out into a busy street and get hit by a bus – it teaches you to wait your turn. If bad decision-makers are bailed out – it punishes good decision-makers and encourages bad decision-making. That sounds not so optimal, huh?
Go after Madoff and recover whatever you can – guy owes you everything he has (including his penthouse suite he currently occupies). He should also be subject to hard labour for the people he screwed. But don’t come after me, my grandmother, some hillbilly in West Virginia, and everyone else. We have nothing to do with this. We didn’t tell you to invest with Madoff. We didn’t tell Madoff to screw you over. We had zero to do with this.
You made a bad decision and you have a bad consequence – that is how things are suppossed to work. Next time, do more research. Next time, diversify. Next time, I wish you better luck. It is a terrible thing – but robbing me and everyone else is the most ridiculous idea of the day.
And the kicker -
The Orthopedic Specialty Group, which decided in 1992 to invest all of its 140 employees’ retirement assets — including employee and company contributions — in Madoff’s funds has so far not filed suit. The office is instead focusing its efforts on getting relief from the federal government.
ARE YOU KIDDING ME??????????????
These fleabag bastards are actually trying to shake me dry out of my own hard-earned coin rather than going after the guy that did it?
W!
T!
F!
Maybe they should hire Madoff to fleece us – although the government does run a pretty specialized practice in that sector.
Unbelievable.